The Proton Size Problem
November 3, 2016
It's easy to measure the diameter of a billiard ball to great accuracy, but not that easy to measure the diameter of a tennis ball. A tennis ball is fuzzy, so it's hard to say where a tennis ball ends and the rest of the universe begins. The same is true of the subatomic particles, which, because of their quantum nature, exist as fuzzy blobs. The electron is an interesting case. While experiments show that it is a "point particle" with no diameter, we must conclude by Heisenberg's uncertainty principle that it does occupy a nonzero volume.
While protons act as if they are charged spheres, the edge of the sphere is not sharply defined. The proton charge radius is therefore taken as a root-mean-squared value. There have been many measurements of this charge radius, and the accepted value is 0.8751 femtometers (fm, 1015 meter) with an uncertainty of about 0.7%.
It's not known why a proton should have a particular charge radius, let alone the particular value that we measure. Also, the proton has a magnetic moment, acting as if it were a spinning ball of charge. Otto Stern discovered the large magnetic moment of the proton, and he was awarded the 1943 Nobel Prize in Physics for this discovery.
Today, we know that the proton is a composite particle composed of three quarks, two up quarks of electric charge +2/3 e and spin 1/2 ↑, and one down quark of electric charge -1/3 e and spin 1/2 ↓. Adding the charges and spins of these gives us the values that we observe for the proton.
As I wrote in two previous articles (Fat Protons, July 12, 2010, and Proton Size Problem, March 20, 2013), proton size measurements based on hydrogen atoms in which muon replace electrons have yielded a significantly smaller charge radius than previous measurements, giving rise to what's now termed the proton radius puzzle.[2-4]
When a hydrogen atom is constructed from a muon and a proton, the proton appears to have a slightly smaller radius than that of a normal hydrogen atom of an electron orbiting a proton. Although muons are 207 times heavier than electrons, all their other properties are identical, and theory predicts that the proton shouldn't behave differently. ArXiv lists 61 papers containing "proton radius" in their title from 2010 to the present.
Muonic hydrogen provides a better system than electonic hydrogen for measurement of the proton charge radius, since the higher mass muon is in a nearer orbit of the proton than an electron. These measurements have been based on pulsed laser spectroscopy of the Lamb shift of the muonic energy levels. The Lamb shift, named after Nobel Physics Laureate, Willis Lamb, is the small difference in energy between the 2S1/2 and 2P1/2 electron energy levels.
This is a difficult experiment, since muons have a mean lifetime of just 2.197 microseconds. In this short time span, you need to create muonic hydrogen and measure the Lamb shift. Fortunately, the experimental teams have been able to create a few hundred muons each second, and a fraction of these replaced electrons in hydrogen gas.
Earlier this year, the same research group that made the original discovery of the proton size problem conducted further experiments using muons with deuterium nuclei, which are protons combined with a neutron, and muons.[5-6] They found a proton radius several standard deviations smaller than that of normal, electron deuterium. These repeated confirmatory measurements show that, aside from some unknown experimental or theoretical error, there might be some new physics to be discovered, such as a previously unknown fundamental force acting between muons and protons, but not between electrons and protons.[5-6]
Some new physics might explain the anomalous magnetic dipole moment of the muon. The lead principal investigator on these experiments, Randolf Pohl of the Max Planck Institute of Quantum Optics (Garching, Germany) is more cautious. The proton size calculation requires a value of the Rydberg constant, which is supposedly known to great accuracy (10 973 731.568 508 m-1). Pohl thinks that the problem might be in this constant.
As typical in the sciences, works continues to unravel the true story. Another team is attempting a measurement that doesn't require the Rydberg constant, and Pohl's group plans to examine muonic helium, a muonic atom with two protons.
|Quark structure of the proton.|
The three quarks (two up and one down) are held together by appropriately named gluons.
(Image by Arpad Horvath, modified, via Wikimedia Commons.)
- NIST, "CODATA Value: proton rms charge radius".
- Randolf Pohl, et al., "The size of the proton," Nature, vol. 466, no. 7303 (July 8, 2010), pp. 213-216.
- Aldo Antognini, et al. "Proton Structure from the Measurement of 2S-2P Transition Frequencies of Muonic Hydrogen," Science, vol. 339 no. 6118 (January 25, 2013), pp. 417-420.
- Helen S. Margolis, "How Big Is the Proton?" Science, vol. 339 no. 6118 (January 25, 2013), pp. 405-406.
- Randolf Pohl, et al., "Laser spectroscopy of muonic deuterium, Science, vol. 353 no. 6300 (August 12, 2016), pp. 669-673, DOI: 10.1126/science.aaf2468.
- Natalie Wolchover, "New Measurement Deepens Proton Puzzle," Quanta Magazine, August 11, 2016.
- NIST, "CODATA Value: Rydberg constant".
Permanent Link to this article
Linked Keywords: Diameter; billiard ball; accuracy; tennis ball; fuzzy; universe; subatomic particle; quantum mechanics; quantum nature; electron; experiment; point particle; Heisenberg's uncertainty principle; volume; Werner Heisenberg; Wolfgang Pauli; Solvay Conference; Wikimedia Commons; proton; electric charge; charged; sphere; charge radius; root-mean-square; femtometer; proton magnetic moment; Otto Stern; Nobel Prize in Physics; composite particle; quark; up quark; spin; down quark; gluon; hydrogen atom; muon; proton radius puzzle; atomic orbital; orbiting; ArXiv; scientific literature; paper; mass; laser; spectroscopy; Lamb shift; energy level; Nobel Physics Laureate; Willis Lamb; energy; Bohr model; hydrogen atom; muon; muonic; Inkscape; exponential decay; mean lifetime; microsecond; hydrogen gas; research; deuterium; atomic nucleus; nuclei; neutron; standard deviation; reproducibility; confirmatory measurement; theory; theoretical; physics; fundamental interaction; fundamental force; anomalous magnetic dipole moment of the muon; principal investigator; Randolf Pohl; calculation; Rydberg constant; science; helium.
Latest Books by Dev Gualtieri
Thanks to Cory Doctorow of BoingBoing for his favorable review of Secret Codes!
Blog Article Directory on a Single Page
- J. Robert Oppenheimer and Black Holes - April 24, 2017
- Modeling Leaf Mass - April 20, 2017
- Easter, Chicks and Eggs - April 13, 2017
- You, Robot - April 10, 2017
- Collisions - April 6, 2017
- Eugene Garfield (1925-2017) - April 3, 2017
- Old Fossils - March 30, 2017
- Levitation - March 27, 2017
- Soybean Graphene - March 23, 2017
- Income Inequality and Geometrical Frustration - March 20, 2017
- Wireless Power - March 16, 2017
- Trilobite Sex - March 13, 2017
- Freezing, Outside-In - March 9, 2017
- Ammonia Synthesis - March 6, 2017
- High Altitude Radiation - March 2, 2017
- C.N. Yang - February 27, 2017
- VOC Detection with Nanocrystals - February 23, 2017
- Molecular Fountains - February 20, 2017
- Jet Lag - February 16, 2017
- Highly Flexible Conductors - February 13, 2017
- Graphene Friction - February 9, 2017
- Dynamic Range - February 6, 2017
- Robert Boyle's To-Do List for Science - February 2, 2017
- Nanowire Ink - January 30, 2017
- Random Triangles - January 26, 2017
- Torricelli's law - January 23, 2017
- Magnetic Memory - January 19, 2017
- Graphene Putty - January 16, 2017
- Seahorse Genome - January 12, 2017
- Infinite c - January 9, 2017
- 150 Years of Transatlantic Telegraphy - January 5, 2017
- Cold Work on the Nanoscale - January 2, 2017
- Holidays 2016 - December 22, 2016
- Ballistics - December 19, 2016
- Salted Frogs - December 15, 2016
- Negative Thermal Expansion - December 12, 2016
- Verbal Cues and Stereotypes - December 8, 2016
- Capacitance Sensing - December 5, 2016
- Gallium Nitride Tribology - December 1, 2016
- Lunar Origin - November 27, 2016
- Pumpkin Propagation - November 24, 2016
- Math Anxiety - November 21, 2016
- Borophene - November 17, 2016
- Forced Innovation - November 14, 2016
- Combating Glare - November 10, 2016
- Solar Tilt and Planet Nine - November 7, 2016
- The Proton Size Problem - November 3, 2016
- Coffee Acoustics and Espresso Foam - October 31, 2016
- SnIP - An Inorganic Double Helix - October 27, 2016
- Seymour Papert (1928-2016) - October 24, 2016
- Mapping the Milky Way - October 20, 2016
- Electromagnetic Shielding - October 17, 2016
- The Lunacy of the Cows - October 13, 2016
- Random Coprimes and Pi - October 10, 2016
- James Cronin (1931-2016) - October 6, 2016
- The Ubiquitous Helix - October 3, 2016
- The Five-Second Rule - September 29, 2016
- Resistor Networks - September 26, 2016
- Brown Dwarfs - September 22, 2016
- Intrusion Rheology - September 19, 2016
- Falsifiability - September 15, 2016
- Fifth Force - September 12, 2016
- Renal Crystal Growth - September 8, 2016
- The Normality of Pi - September 5, 2016
- Metering Electrical Power - September 1, 2016
Deep Archive 2006-2008